Last updated: 2026-11-20

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander: Reliability Compared

Reliability is effectively tied between the Toyota Highlander and Nissan Pathfinder, so the choice comes down to which problems you can live with. The Pathfinder has far fewer recalls and complaints. The Highlander costs slightly less to maintain and visits the shop less often.

How Do the Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander Generations Compare?

Most used Highlander shoppers will land in the fourth generation, which covers 2020 through 2026. Its weakest year, 2021, comes early in that cycle. The 2018 and 2019 years belong to the third generation, which got a refresh for 2017, and 2019 closes out that run. A fifth generation is listed for 2027. The Pathfinder splits across two generations. The 2018 year sits in the fourth generation, which ran from 2013 to 2020 and was facelifted for 2017. The fifth generation started with 2022 and was facelifted for 2023. Its weakest year, 2022, is the first of that redesign, so a 2023 may be the safer pick within it.

Verdict

The Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander are evenly matched with a reliability score of 73/100.

Reliability is effectively tied. Both stand at good, and neither pulls ahead in a way that should decide the purchase. The Pathfinder has far fewer recalls and complaints, while the Highlander costs a bit less to keep running. What separates them is the kind of failure. The Highlander's worst reports involve transmission failure, lost brake assist, and air bags that did not deploy. The Pathfinder's involve early rear brake wear, stalling, and water leaks. Pick on the specific risks, not on a winner.

Biggest gaps

  1. Nissan Pathfinder has 30 fewer total recalls
  2. Nissan Pathfinder has 10.1 fewer complaints per 10k sold
  3. Toyota Highlander needs 0.1 fewer repairs per year

Round by round

  • Reliability ScoreDraw
  • Total RecallsPathfinder
  • Complaint RatePathfinder
  • Annual Repair CostHighlander
  • Repair FrequencyHighlander
  • Major Repair RiskHighlander
  • Safety RatingDraw

Leaning Nissan Pathfinder or Toyota Highlander? Check the exact car before you buy

Whichever wins on paper, the car in front of you has its own past. A VIN check shows its accidents, title history and any open recalls.

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander: Which Is More Reliable?

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander at-a-glance reliability comparison
MetricNissan PathfinderToyota Highlander
Reliability Score73/10073/100
Years Tracked89
Total Recalls1444
Complaints per 10k Sold4.814.9
Annual Repair Cost$542/yr$489/yr
Repair Frequency0.4/yr0.3/yr
Major Repair Risk15%13%
Safety Rating2026 NHTSA2026 NHTSA
Frontal
Side
Rollover
Year Wins44

What Are the Common Problems With the Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander?

High-stakes failures dominate the Highlander's complaints. A whine from the 8-speed automatic is the early sign of transmission failure, and some cars lost all acceleration in traffic. Brake booster vacuum pump failures drop power assist without warning. Air bags lead on crash links by a wide margin, with owners reporting no deployment in serious collisions. The Pathfinder's complaints lean toward nuisance and repeat visits: rear pads and rotors worn out early, engine stalls dealers cannot reproduce, and rain leaking through the roof or hatch. Its stalling and electrical shutdowns while driving are still a real concern, but its crash links are few. It has no air bag category in its top five.

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander common problem areas comparison
Nissan PathfinderProblem areaToyota Highlander
0.4
Transmission
4.6
1.0
Brakes
1.5
0.6
Engine
0.8
0.1
Body and structure
1.2
0.6
Electrical
0.7
0.1
Fuel system
1.1
0.1
Airbags
1.0
0.1
Seats
0.3
0.1
Acceleration and cruise control
0.1
0.2
Wipers and visibility
<0.1
<0.1
Automatic emergency braking
<0.1
<0.1
Seat belts
<0.1
<0.1
Steering
<0.1
<0.1
Backup camera
0
0
Wheels and tires
<0.1
<0.1
Stability control
0
<0.1
Suspension
0
0.7
Other or unspecified
1.6

Complaints per 10,000 units sold, aggregated across all tracked model years from NHTSA owner reports. Shorter bars mean fewer complaints.

Which Is Cheaper to Maintain: Nissan Pathfinder or Toyota Highlander?

Nissan Pathfinder$542/yr · $2,710 over 5 years
Toyota Highlander$489/yr · $2,445 over 5 years
Keeping the Highlander on the road costs less, at $489 a year against $542 for the Pathfinder. Over five years, that gap comes to about $265. The Highlander also needs fewer unscheduled shop visits, 0.3 a year against 0.4. Its chance of a major repair is 13%, against 15% for the Pathfinder. The differences are small. A single transmission replacement quote of $8,000 or more, reported by Highlander owners, would wipe out the savings many times over.

How Does Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander Reliability Compare by Year?

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander year-by-year reliability scores
YearNissan PathfinderToyota Highlander
202682/1000 recalls · 17 complaints88/1000 recalls · 4 complaints
202577/1001 recall · 64 complaints76/1004 recalls · 11 complaints
202471/1002 recalls · 88 complaints75/1007 recalls · 43 complaints
202373/1001 recall · 108 complaints71/1009 recalls · 203 complaints
202266/1005 recalls · 137 complaints71/1006 recalls · 279 complaints
202076/1000 recalls · 53 complaints70/1005 recalls · 334 complaints
201970/1002 recalls · 76 complaints68/1003 recalls · 520 complaints
201868/1003 recalls · 79 complaints71/1005 recalls · 283 complaints

Best years to cross-shop: The 2020 Nissan Pathfinder scored 76/100 and the 2024 Toyota Highlander scored 75/100, the strongest shared model years that have been on the road for at least two years, where available.

Who Should Buy the Nissan Pathfinder vs the Toyota Highlander?

Team Highlander

Choose the Highlander if you want lower running costs and fewer trips to the shop. Its repair-cost data is a little better. Shop carefully, though. Skip the 2021 and 2019 model years, its weakest, and ask any seller whether the transmission has whined, slipped, or been replaced. Check the brake booster vacuum pump history too. The 2025 and 2026 years look clean, but they have had little time to collect complaints, so do not read that as proof.

Choose the Pathfinder if the Highlander's transmission and air bag reports worry you, since the Pathfinder has far fewer complaints and recalls on file. Plan on early rear brake jobs, and ask for service records showing when the rear pads and rotors were last replaced. Avoid the 2022 and 2018 model years, its weakest. Test drive it at stops with auto start/stop on, and check the headliner, hatch, and sunroof for water stains or a musty smell.

Nissan Pathfinder vs Toyota Highlander: Common Questions

Is the Toyota Highlander more reliable than the Nissan Pathfinder?
No, they are effectively tied, and both stand at good. The Highlander has lower repair costs and fewer shop visits. The Pathfinder has far fewer recalls and complaints. The Highlander's problems skew toward transmission failure and brake assist loss, while the Pathfinder's skew toward early rear brake wear and stalling.
Which has more recalls, the Highlander or the Pathfinder?
The Highlander has more. Federal recall records show 44 recalls across its 9 model years from 2018 to 2026. The Pathfinder has 14 across 8 model years. Owner complaints follow the same pattern, at 14.9 per 10,000 sold for the Highlander and 4.8 for the Pathfinder.
Which costs less to repair, the Highlander or the Pathfinder?
The Highlander costs less. Independent repair-cost data puts it at $489 a year against $542 for the Pathfinder, about $265 over five years. It also has a lower chance that a repair is major, at 13% against 15%, and fewer unscheduled shop visits each year.
What is the most common Highlander problem?
Power train problems lead, with 735 owner complaints. A high-pitched whine from the 8-speed automatic, often between 25 and 45 mph, is the usual first sign of transmission failure. Failures range from 39,000 to 136,000 miles, and dealer replacement quotes reach $8,000 or more.
Do Nissan Pathfinder rear brakes wear out early?
Many owners say so. Service brakes are the Pathfinder's top complaint area, with 124 reports. Rear pads and rotors often wear to metal between 16,000 and 27,000 miles while the fronts still have material. Dealers often call it normal wear and refuse warranty coverage, so ask for brake service records.

Decided between Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander? Run a VIN check before you buy — uncover hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls.

Look Up a VIN →

How we score the Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander

Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

See incorrect data? Report an issue