Last updated: 2026-11-19

2019 Toyota Highlander
68
GoodReliability score: 68 out of 100, rated Good

Reliability score

Good · #8 of 9 scored Highlander years

2019 Toyota Highlander Reliability Report

The 2019 Toyota Highlander has good reliability, but owners report transmission whine and failure from about 50,000 miles, plus stalling.

Recalls

3

Complaints

520

Complaint Rate

21.7per 10,000 sold

Est. Repair Cost

$489

Annual Fuel Cost

$2,600–2,700

Detailed Score Breakdown

Complaint Severity35% of score51/100

Component-weighted complaints normalized by sales volume

Repair Costs30% of score80/100

Independent repair cost ratings

Recall Impact20% of score75/100

Recall count weighted by severity

Issue Diversity15% of score76/100

Breadth of reported problem categories

The verdict

Consider

Last of the third generation, with good reliability but a weaker showing than most Highlander years, driven by transmission whine and stalling complaints.

Looking at a used 2019 Toyota Highlander? Check that exact car

3 recalls cover this year. A VIN check shows whether the car you found had the work done, plus accidents, title and odometer history.

Generation & Refresh (US)

Final Year

2019 is the last model year of the Third generation (XU50).

  • Final-year models are typically the most refined version of a generation.
  • 3 years after the last refresh (2016).
  • 3rd generation Highlander (US).

What this means for buyers

Final-year models are usually the most polished version of a generation, but resale value may dip as buyers anticipate the next redesign.

2014: Third generation (XU50) Launch

Generation start — new platform.

2016: Mid-Cycle Refresh

Updated features and styling tweaks.

2019: This Model Year

2019 is the last model year of the Third generation (XU50).

Should You Buy the 2019 Toyota Highlander?

Good, but not the pick of the Highlander lineup. Owner complaints put this final third-generation year close to average among 2019 SUVs, and among the weaker of the nine scored Highlander years. It earns a 5 of 5 federal crash rating, and model-wide repair costs run about $489 a year against $573 for the class. The 2018 rates better. The 2020 rates about the same.

The big issue is the automatic transmission. Owners describe a rising whine under acceleration, often between 20 and 40 mph, then a verdict that the transmission needs replacing. Most cases show up between about 50,000 and 117,000 miles, and quoted costs often top $10,000. Others report harsh or delayed shifts and sudden power loss with no warning light. Stalling is the second theme, tied by some owners to the fuel pump or to failed fuel injectors. Hybrid owners report power loss with Hybrid System Malfunction warnings. Federal records list 3 recalls, including two for the gasoline fuel system.

Before buying, ask for proof that the recalls were completed. Check the service history for transmission or fuel pump work, and test drive between 20 and 40 mph listening for a whine. The 2018 is worth a look as well.

Compared to the 2020 Toyota Highlander, which scored 2 points higher. See also the 2018 Toyota Highlander for an earlier comparison.

Pros

  • Acceptable reliability score
  • $84 cheaper to maintain than avg midsize SUVs
  • Infrequent unscheduled repairs
  • Low major repair risk13%

Cons

  • Moderate recall count
  • TransmissionRising whine under acceleration, often between 20 and 40 mph, dominates these...200 complaints
  • Fuel systemSudden stalling while driving is the main complaint65 complaints

Compare 2019 Toyota Highlander With

Recall Overview

3

recalls on record

A moderate 3 recalls are on file for the 2019 Toyota Highlander. Each one points to a specific safety or compliance issue identified by the manufacturer or NHTSA — check the list below before buying.

NHTSA.gov →

Complaint Breakdown

21.7

per 10,000 sold

Segment avg: 26.7

LowAvgHigh
Moderate

Safety Incidents

22

Crashes

1

Fires

18

Injuries

0

Deaths

★★★★★

NHTSA 5/5 Stars

Data sourced from NHTSA complaint filings and manufacturer recall notices. Complaint narratives are owner-reported.

2019 Toyota Highlander Recall Details

3 recalls have been issued for the 2019 Toyota Highlander. Recall repairs are free at authorized dealers, so check that each one below was done on the car you are looking at.

EquipmentRecall 19V244000Mar 27, 2019

The text on the load capacity label may become illegible.

As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) number 110, "Tire Selection and Rims."

Risk
If the driver cannot read the label, they may unknowingly overload the vehicle, increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix
GST will notify owners, and dealers will provide corrected load carrying capacity modification labels, free of charge.
Which vehicles are covered

Gulf States Toyota (GST) is recalling certain 2019 C-HR, 4Runner, Avalon, Avalon Hybrid, Camry, Camry Hybrid, Highlander, Land Cruiser, Prius, RAV4, Sequoia, Tacoma, Sienna, Tundra and Yaris vehicles.

More about the fix

The recall began May 24, 2019. Owners may contact GST customer service at 1-800-444-1074. GST's number for this recall is 19R1.

Fuel systemRecall 20V012000Jan 13, 2020

Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing (Toyota) recalled certain 2018-2019 4Runner, Highlander, Camry, Land Cruiser, Sequoia, Sienna, Tacoma and Tundra, and Lexus RC 300, RC 350, GS 350, GX 460, IS 300, LC 500, LS 500, LX 570, RX 350L, and 2019 Toyota Avalon and Corolla, and certain Lexus NX 300, and ES 350 vehicles on January 13, 2020.

On March 4, 2020, Toyota expanded the recall to include certain 2014-2015 Toyota 4Runner and Land Cruiser, 2018 Avalon, Corolla, 2014 FJ Cruiser, 2017 Sienna and Lexus 2018 ES 350, 2018-2019 GS 300, 2013-2014 GS350, 2014-2015 GX 460, IS 350 and LX 570, 2014 IS F, 2018-2019 IS 350, LC 500H and LS 500H, 2013-2015 LS 460, 2015 NX 200T and RC350, 2017 RC 200T and RX 350. Toyota also removed the 2018-2019 Toyota 4Runner and Land Cruiser and 2018-2019 Lexus GX 460 and LX 570 and 2019 NX300 from inclusion in this recall. On March 19, 2020, Toyota expanded the recall to include 2015 Lexus GS350 vehicles. The low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank may fail.

Risk
If the fuel pump fails, the engine can stall while driving, increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix
Toyota will notify owners, and dealers will replace the fuel pump, free of charge.
More about the fix

The recall began May 4, 2020. Owners may contact Toyota customer service at 1-888-270-9371 or Lexus customer service at 1-800-255-3987. Toyota's numbers for this recall are 20TB02 and 20TA02 for Toyota vehicles and 20LB01 and 20LA01 for Lexus vehicles.

Fuel systemRecall 20V682000Nov 4, 2020

The low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank may fail.

Risk
If the fuel pump fails, the engine can stall while driving, increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix
Toyota will notify owners, and dealers will replace the fuel pump assembly with an improved one, free of charge.
Which vehicles are covered

Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing (Toyota) is recalling certain 2018-2019 4Runner, 2019-2020 Avalon, 2019 Corolla Hatchback, 2017-2019 Highlander, 2018-2020 Camry, 2020 Corolla, 2018-2019 Land Cruiser, 2017-2020 Tacoma, 2019-2020 RAV4, 2019-2020 Sequoia, 2017-2020 Sienna, 2019-2020 Tundra, 2018-2020 Lexus ES350, 2017 Lexus GS200t, 2017-2019 Lexus GS350, 2019 Lexus GS300, 2018-2020 Lexus LC500h, 2019-2020 Lexus LS500, 2018-2019 Lexus GX460, 2017 Lexus IS200t, 2019 Lexus IS300, 2019 Lexus IS350, 2018-2020 Lexus LC500, 2018 Lexus LS500, 2019 Lexus LS500h, 2018-2019 Lexus LX570, 2017 Lexus RC200t, 2019 Lexus RC300, RC350, 2017 and 2019-2020 Lexus RX350, 2018-2020 RX350L, 2019 Lexus UX200, 2018-2019 Lexus NX300 vehicles.

More about the fix

Owners of specific models were notified that remedy parts were available starting January 21, 2021. Owners of other models will be notified as remedy parts become available. Remedy parts should be available for all affected vehicles by late March 2021. Owners may contact Toyota customer service at 1-888-270-9371 or Lexus customer service at 1-800-255-3987. Note: This recall is an expansion of recall 20V-012. Toyota's number for this recall is 20TA02. Lexus' number for this recall is 20LA01.

VIN History Report

Buying a used 2019 Toyota Highlander? Check its history first

Power train problems lead owner complaints about the 2019 Toyota Highlander, and 3 recalls were issued for it. A VIN check shows whether this car's recall work was done, plus accident, title, and odometer history.

No VIN? Just hit “Check VIN” to look one up.

  • Accidents
  • Open Recalls
  • Title History
  • Odometer Rollback

2019 Toyota Highlander NHTSA Safety Ratings

Overall Safety Rating

Overall safety rating: 5 out of 5
Crash Test Results by Configuration (expand)

Gas Powertrain

Driver: 4/5Passenger: 5/5

Rollover risk: 18.5%

Safety Technologies

Dynamic Head Restraints (Not Available)Head Restraint (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Advanced Belt Feature (Standard)Adjustable Upper Belt Anchorage (Driver, Front Passenger)Seat Belt Reminder System (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Frontal Air Bag (Driver, Front Passenger)Curtain (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Torso/Pelvis (Driver, Front Passenger)Knee (Driver)Additional Air Bags (Seat Pan Air Bags)Meets Side Air Bag Out-of-Position Requirements (Yes)LATCH Locations (Rear Seat)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) (Standard)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) locations (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat)

HEV Powertrain

Driver: 4/5Passenger: 5/5

Rollover risk: 16.9%

Safety Technologies

Dynamic Head Restraints (Not Available)Head Restraint (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Advanced Belt Feature (Standard)Adjustable Upper Belt Anchorage (Driver, Front Passenger)Seat Belt Reminder System (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Frontal Air Bag (Driver, Front Passenger)Curtain (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat, 3rd row)Torso/Pelvis (Driver, Front Passenger)Knee (Driver)Additional Air Bags (Seat Pan Air Bags)Meets Side Air Bag Out-of-Position Requirements (Yes)LATCH Locations (Rear Seat)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) (Standard)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) locations (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat)
View full safety data on NHTSA.gov →

Toyota Highlander Repair Costs & Maintenance

Maintenance Rating

4Maintenance rating: 4 out of 5

Based on NHTSA complaint patterns, recall severity, and publicly available cost benchmarks.

Est. Annual Maintenance

$489

vs $573 avg for midsize SUVs

vs $652 avg for all vehicles

Repair Frequency

0.3

unscheduled repair visits per year

Severe Repair Probability

13%

chance of a major repair

Annual Cost Comparison

Highlander
$489
Category Avg
$573
All Vehicles
$652

Category-level averages derived from publicly available industry reports (AAA, CarMD). Model-level estimates produced by Auto Reliability Index.

Toyota Highlander Resale Value

The Toyota Highlander is estimated to retain about 71.1% of its original value after 5 years, based on observed used-car listings.

This benchmark covers the Toyota Highlander model overall and is not specific to the 2019 model year.

Value Retained
71.1%

after 5 years

Depreciation
28.9%

over the same period

Listings Analyzed
720

U.S. used-car listings

Listings observed in . Actual resale value varies by trim, mileage, condition, and location.

Explore Toyota Highlander depreciation and resale value on CarResaleValue.com

MPG & Annual Running Costs

Gas

22–23 MPG

Running cost: $3,100–$3,200/yr

Fuel + repair

19–21 city / 24–27 hwy MPG

Hybrid

28–29 MPG

Running cost: $2,550–$2,650/yr

Fuel + repair

29–30 city / 27–28 hwy MPG

Running cost includes EPA fuel-cost estimate and independent repair-cost data (repair cost estimated at model level). Excludes routine maintenance, depreciation, and insurance. Data as of 2019 EPA label cycle.

Gas trims
TrimDriveTrans.CityHwyCombFuel Cost
Highlander 3.5L 6-cylFront-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S8)202723$2,600
Highlander AWD LE 3.5L 6-cylAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S8)202723$2,600
Highlander LE/XLE/SE/LTD 3.5L 6-cylFront-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S8)212723$2,600
Highlander 2.7L 4-cylFront-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S6)202422$2,700
Highlander AWD 3.5L 6-cylAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S8)192622$2,700
Highlander AWD 3.5L 6-cylAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (S8)202622$2,700
Hybrid trims
TrimDriveTrans.CityHwyCombFuel Cost
Highlander Hybrid AWD LE Plus 3.5L 6-cylAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (AV-S6)302829$2,050
Highlander Hybrid AWD 3.5L 6-cylAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (AV-S6)292728$2,150

Used Buying Checklist

Key things to inspect or verify before purchasing a 2019 Toyota Highlander.

  • Accelerate gently from 20 to 40 mph with the radio off and listen for a rising whine.

  • Ask for service records showing any transmission replacement or whine complaint, especially past 50,000 miles.

  • Run the VIN for open recalls and request records of any fuel pump or fuel injector work.

  • Test navigation voice guidance and hands-free calling right after a cold start.

  • Press the brake firmly at a stop and walk away if the pedal sinks or Braking Power Low appears.

  • Confirm no airbag, hybrid system, or Check Engine warnings appear on the dash during a long test drive.

  • Inspect the sunroof glass for cracks and listen for excessive wind noise above 30 mph.

  • Check that the driver's floor mat is secured and cannot slide under the accelerator pedal.

Going to see one? Take the printable 2019 Toyota Highlander inspection checklist with you.

2019 Toyota Highlander Common Problems by Component

520 owner complaints grouped by vehicle system.

200
65
65
62
POWER TRAIN (200)UNKNOWN OR OTHER (65)FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM (65)ENGINE (41)ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (39)FUEL SYSTEM (21)SERVICE BRAKES (14)AIR BAGS (13)Other (62)

POWER TRAIN

200 complaints

Highlander transmission problems across all model years

A rising whine under acceleration, often between 20 and 40 mph, dominates these reports. Dealers sometimes blame tires, brakes, or alignment first, then conclude the automatic transmission must be replaced rather than repaired. Most cases surface between about 50,000 and 117,000 miles, many just past the powertrain warranty. Some owners also describe harsh or delayed shifts, shuddering, and sudden loss of power at speed with no warning light. Quoted replacement costs often top $10,000, and some owners wait weeks for back-ordered parts.

200 complaints total

UNKNOWN OR OTHER

65 complaintsSafety-related

This catch-all mixes transmission failures with unrelated defects. Several reports describe the transmission whining, slipping, or quitting between about 70,000 and 90,000 miles, leaving the car unable to go past 20 mph. Limited and Platinum owners report navigation with no voice guidance, sometimes fixed only by restarting. Other reports cover an ear-splitting screech from the SOS system at startup, a sunroof shattering on the freeway, perfumed air from the rear vents, and hybrids losing power. Two crashes involved the car surging or rolling unexpectedly.

65 complaints total2 crashes3 injuries

FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM

65 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander fuel system problems across all model years

Sudden stalling while driving is the main complaint. It happens at intersections, on inclines, and in busy traffic, sometimes with a Check Engine or master caution light and sometimes with none. Several owners tie it to the fuel pump. Others report failed fuel injectors around 30,000 to 38,000 miles, with the car dropping into low power. Hybrid owners describe sudden sluggishness with Hybrid System Malfunction warnings. Other reports cover lag when accelerating from a stop and fuel spilling at the pump. One crash with an injury involved the car lunging forward at low speed.

65 complaints total1 crash1 injury
ENGINE (41 complaints)

ENGINE

41 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander engine problems across all model years

Despite the heading, most reports here describe the transmission. Symptoms include a whine on acceleration around 25 to 40 mph, high revs with little forward movement, and a car that will not move at all. Replacement is advised between about 50,000 and 110,000 miles. True engine complaints include stalling in commuter traffic, a high idle that makes the car lurch off the brake, and hybrid warnings with power lag. One report describes a scored cylinder burning oil and coolant. One crash involved unintended acceleration at parking-lot speed.

41 complaints total1 crash
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (39 complaints)

ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

39 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander electrical problems across all model years

Two failures dominate. Hybrid models lose power or stall without warning, then flash Hybrid System Malfunction, Pre-Collision, Check Engine, and AWD warnings, sometimes with heavy steering. Dealers often cannot reproduce it. Separately, navigation and voice command go silent, leaving no spoken directions or hands-free calling, and some head units reboot on their own. A few owners report the car failing to start. Two crashes, one with injuries, involved sudden surging while reversing or parking.

39 complaints total2 crashes3 injuries
FUEL SYSTEM (21 complaints)

FUEL SYSTEM

21 complaints

Highlander fuel system problems across all model years

Most filings come from owners who say they received a fuel-system recall notice but were told the repair part was not yet available, leaving them waiting with no fix. Those who had failures describe the engine stalling without warning at 35 to 45 mph or in stop-and-go traffic, sometimes restarting after a pause. Check Engine and traction control lights appear in some cases. One owner reports jarring that returned even after a fuel pump replacement.

21 complaints total
SERVICE BRAKES (14 complaints)

SERVICE BRAKES

14 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander brake problems across all model years

A brake pedal that sinks to the floor or barely slows the car is the core complaint, often with a Braking Power Low warning and sometimes with the hybrid system shutting down. Dealers frequently cannot find a cause. Repairs owners cite include the master cylinder, brake booster, and brake actuator. Some hybrids also grab abruptly when coasting to a stop near 4 mph. Three crashes are reported, including one where the SUV rolled backward from Park with passengers inside.

14 complaints total3 crashes2 injuries
AIR BAGS (13 complaints)

AIR BAGS

13 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander airbag problems across all model years

Airbags failing to deploy in real collisions is the main concern. Seven crash reports describe T-bone, rear-end, underride, and rollover impacts at roughly 25 to 45 mph with no deployment, several with injuries. Other owners report SRS airbag malfunction warnings that dealers reset without a lasting fix, seatbelts not registering as buckled, a rear passenger airbag firing while driving, and water from a clogged evaporator box damaging the airbag control module.

13 complaints total7 crashes5 injuries
STRUCTURE (8 complaints)

STRUCTURE

8 complaintsSafety-related

Highlander body and structure problems across all model years

Sunroof glass shattering on its own while driving is the most serious pattern. It happens at about 30 to 65 mph with nothing striking the roof, and closed sunshades kept glass off occupants. Limited and Platinum owners also report loud wind noise that dealers call a design trait and could not fix. Other reports cover a front bumper that keeps popping out and one crash where the parked vehicle rolled backward and dragged the driver.

8 complaints total2 crashes1 injury
VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL (6 complaints)

VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL

6 complaintsSafety-related

Unintended acceleration while parking appears in two crash reports, one blamed on the pedal catching the floor mat, with the car stopping only after it was shut off. Other reports describe hesitation and loss of power when merging onto highways, which owners link to the 8-speed automatic transmission and its whine under acceleration. In one case the problem returned after a transmission replacement. Adaptive cruise control also accelerated toward a car ahead in snow before warning that the sensor was blocked.

6 complaints total2 crashes1 injury

When Do 2019 Toyota Highlander Problems Start?

Based on owner complaint patterns, here’s when common issues tend to appear.

50,000–117,000 milesTransmission whine and failure
5,000–15,000 milesStalling from fuel pump

Best & Worst Toyota Highlander Years

Toyota Highlander reliability score trend

Scores 0–100, higher is better. Best and worst years are ringed. This year is highlighted.

Toyota Highlander reliability scores by year
YearScoreRating
201871/100Good
201968/100Good
202070/100Good
202167/100Good
202271/100Good
202371/100Good
202475/100Good
202576/100Good
202688/100Excellent

Toyota Highlander Reliability Compared to Other Years

Reliability scores compared across model years
YearScorevs Prior YearRatingRecallsComplaints
202688/100+12Excellent04
202576/100+1Good411
202475/100+4Good743
202371/1000Good9203
202271/100+4Good6279
202167/100-3Good5562
202070/100+2Good5334
2019(selected)68/100-3Good3520
201871/100—Good5283

2019 Toyota Highlander Reliability by Powertrain

The 2019 Toyota Highlander is available with 2 powertrain options. Here’s how they compare on reliability.

Reliability comparison across powertrain options
PowertrainComplaintsRecallsIncidents*Crash Rating
Gas5143235 out of 5
HEV6305 out of 5
Total520323

NHTSA tracks complaints by vehicle configuration when that detail is available. Model-level reports that do not identify a specific powertrain are included in Total but not assigned to a row. A plus sign indicates a confirmed minimum; — means no complaints could be attributed to that specific powertrain. N/T = Not tested by NHTSA.

* Incidents = crash + fire reports. A single complaint can include multiple incident types.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 2019 Toyota Highlander reliable?
Yes, it has a good reliability standing, though it is close to average among 2019 SUVs. Within the Highlander's scored years it is among the weaker of nine. Owners filed 520 complaints, mostly about the transmission. It earns a 5 of 5 federal crash rating.
What are the most common problems with the 2019 Toyota Highlander?
Transmission trouble leads, with 200 power train complaints about a whine under acceleration, harsh or delayed shifts, and power loss. Next come fuel system complaints, mainly sudden stalling. Electrical complaints involve hybrid power loss with warning lights, and navigation and voice command going silent.
Does the 2019 Toyota Highlander have transmission problems?
Owners report them often. The usual sign is a whine under acceleration, commonly between 20 and 40 mph. Cases mostly appear between about 50,000 and 117,000 miles. Dealers often advise replacement, with quoted costs frequently above $10,000, and some owners wait weeks for parts.
How many recalls does the 2019 Toyota Highlander have?
Federal recall records list 3 recalls for this model year. Two fall under the gasoline fuel system, and one is in the equipment category. The 2018 has 5 recalls and the 2020 has 5. Ask the seller for proof that all recall work was done.
Is the 2019 Toyota Highlander better than the 2018 or 2020?
The 2018 rates better, with 283 complaints and 5 recalls. The 2020 rates about the same, with 334 complaints and 5 recalls. The 2019 drew 520 complaints, more than either neighbor, though it has fewer recalls. All three have good reliability.

Don’t buy a 2019 Toyota Highlander without checking its VIN first — hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls could cost you thousands.

Look Up a VIN →

How we score the 2019 Toyota Highlander

Of the four inputs behind this score, the 2019 Toyota Highlander does best on repair costs (80/100) and worst on complaint severity (51/100). Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

Get notified when new recalls or reliability data is added for the Toyota Highlander.

No spam. Only data updates for this model.

See incorrect data? Report an issue