Last updated: 2026-11-20

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander: Reliability Compared

Reliability comes out clearly in favor of the Toyota Highlander over the Honda Pilot. The Highlander costs less to repair and needs fewer unscheduled shop visits. Its risk is transmission and brake failure. The Pilot mostly suffers electronic faults.

How Do the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander Generations Compare?

A fourth generation, covering 2020 through 2026, is where most newer used Highlanders sit. A fifth generation is listed for the 2027 model year. The 2018 and 2019 cars belong to the third generation, which was refreshed for 2017. Its weakest years, 2019 and 2021, fall on either side of the change between generations, so judge each car on its own history. The Pilot's fourth generation began in 2023 and received a facelift for 2026. Its third generation ran from 2016 to 2022 and was refreshed for 2019. The weakest Pilot years, 2019 and 2020, belong to that older generation, so a 2023 or newer Pilot avoids them.

Verdict

The Toyota Highlander is more reliable than the Honda Pilot, scoring 73/100 vs 65/100.

Reliability favors the Highlander by a clear margin. Independent repair-cost data puts it at $489 a year against $542 for the Pilot, with 0.3 unscheduled shop visits a year against 0.5. Federal recall records also show fewer recalls, 44 against 51. The Highlander's failures can be harsher, including transmission failure and lost brake assist, and owners filed more complaints per car sold, 14.9 per 10,000 against 11.7. The chance that a repair turns major is 13% on both.

Biggest gaps

  1. Toyota Highlander needs 0.2 fewer repairs per year
  2. Honda Pilot has 3.2 fewer complaints per 10k sold
  3. Toyota Highlander has 7 fewer total recalls

Round by round

  • Reliability ScoreHighlander
  • Total RecallsHighlander
  • Complaint RatePilot
  • Annual Repair CostHighlander
  • Repair FrequencyHighlander
  • Major Repair RiskDraw
  • Safety RatingDraw

Leaning Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander? Check the exact car before you buy

Whichever wins on paper, the car in front of you has its own past. A VIN check shows its accidents, title history and any open recalls.

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander: Which Is More Reliable?

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander at-a-glance reliability comparison
MetricHonda PilotToyota Highlander
Reliability Score65/10073/100
Years Tracked99
Total Recalls5144
Complaints per 10k Sold11.714.9
Annual Repair Cost$542/yr$489/yr
Repair Frequency0.5/yr0.3/yr
Major Repair Risk13%13%
Safety Rating2026 NHTSA2026 NHTSA
Frontal
Side
Rollover
Year Wins09

What Are the Common Problems With the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander?

Drivetrain and safety hardware dominate Highlander complaints, while electronics dominate the Pilot's. Highlander owners describe a whine from the 8-speed automatic that leads to hard shifts, slipping and limp mode, and a brake booster vacuum pump that drops power assist and leaves a stiff pedal. Air bags carry 49 crash-linked complaints of non-deployment. Pilot owners describe screens and gauges going black, idle stop failing to restart the engine, a failed windshield camera, and fuel injector faults. No Pilot problem area has more than 5 crash-linked complaints, and its air bags and brakes are not among its top five.

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander common problem areas comparison
Honda PilotProblem areaToyota Highlander
0.7
Transmission
4.6
2.4
Electrical
0.7
2.0
Engine
0.8
1.2
Fuel system
1.1
0.6
Brakes
1.5
<0.1
Body and structure
1.2
0.2
Airbags
1.0
1.0
Automatic emergency braking
<0.1
0.3
Steering
<0.1
0.3
Seat belts
<0.1
0
Seats
0.3
0.2
Wipers and visibility
<0.1
<0.1
Acceleration and cruise control
0.1
0.2
Backup camera
0
<0.1
Lane keeping
0
0
Wheels and tires
<0.1
1.0
Other or unspecified
1.6

Complaints per 10,000 units sold, aggregated across all tracked model years from NHTSA owner reports. Shorter bars mean fewer complaints.

Which Is Cheaper to Maintain: Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander?

Honda Pilot$542/yr · $2,710 over 5 years
Toyota Highlander$489/yr · $2,445 over 5 years
A gap of $53 a year separates the two: $489 for the Highlander against $542 for the Pilot, or about $265 over five years. The gap is small. The shop-visit difference is larger in proportion: 0.3 unscheduled visits a year for the Highlander against 0.5 for the Pilot. Once a repair is needed, the odds of it being major are identical at 13%, so neither model shields you from a large bill. Highlander transmission replacement quotes reached $8,000 or more.

How Does Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Reliability Compare by Year?

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander year-by-year reliability scores
YearHonda PilotToyota Highlander
202672/1000 recalls · 37 complaints88/1000 recalls · 4 complaints
202567/1004 recalls · 220 complaints76/1004 recalls · 11 complaints
202471/1006 recalls · 122 complaints75/1007 recalls · 43 complaints
202369/1005 recalls · 156 complaints71/1009 recalls · 203 complaints
202268/1003 recalls · 184 complaints71/1006 recalls · 279 complaints
202162/1008 recalls · 462 complaints67/1005 recalls · 562 complaints
202059/1009 recalls · 500 complaints70/1005 recalls · 334 complaints
201954/10011 recalls · 935 complaints68/1003 recalls · 520 complaints
201863/1005 recalls · 443 complaints71/1005 recalls · 283 complaints

Best years to cross-shop: The 2024 Honda Pilot scored 71/100 and the 2024 Toyota Highlander scored 75/100, the strongest shared model years that have been on the road for at least two years, where available.

Who Should Buy the Honda Pilot vs the Toyota Highlander?

Team Highlander

Pick the Highlander if low running cost matters most. It has the lower repair estimate, fewer shop visits and fewer recalls. Skip 2019 and 2021, its weakest years. Before buying any Highlander, ask the seller to confirm the VIN against Toyota's transmission support program, because some owners with the same symptoms found theirs excluded. Test the brakes for a stiff pedal or a "Braking Power Low" message.

Team Pilot

Pick the Pilot if you can live with electronic glitches and want fewer severe-failure reports. Its owners mostly describe blank screens, camera faults and injector codes, and its crash-linked totals are lower. Avoid 2019 and 2020, its weakest years. The 2024 model year ranks among its strongest. The 2026 year ranks well too, but it has had little time to collect complaints, so do not read it as proven. Check that the screen and gauges stay on during a long test drive, and have injector warranty coverage checked by VIN.

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander: Common Questions

Is the Toyota Highlander more reliable than the Honda Pilot?
Yes, by a clear margin. The Highlander has a lower estimated annual repair cost, fewer unscheduled shop visits and fewer recalls. The catch is that its failures can be more serious, including transmission whine that leads to limp mode and brake booster pump failures. Major-repair odds are equal at 13%.
Which has more recalls, the Highlander or the Pilot?
The Pilot has more. Federal recall records show 51 recalls across its 9 model years from 2018 to 2026, against 44 for the Highlander. A recall is a free fix, so the count alone does not make a car worse. Check any specific VIN for open recalls before buying.
Which costs less to repair, the Highlander or the Pilot?
The Highlander costs less. Independent repair-cost data estimates $489 a year for it and $542 for the Pilot, a gap of about $265 over five years. Highlander owners also make fewer unscheduled shop visits, 0.3 a year against 0.5 for the Pilot.
What goes wrong most often on the Honda Pilot?
Electrical faults lead, with 616 owner complaints. The center screen and gauge cluster go black or reboot while driving, and some cars shut off at lights when auto idle stop fails to restart them. Engine power loss, windshield camera failures and fuel injector faults round out the main problems.
What is the biggest safety concern on the Toyota Highlander?
Air bags carry the most crash-linked complaints, 49, with owners reporting no deployment in serious collisions. Brakes are the next concern: a failed vacuum pump removes power assist and stiffens the pedal. Transmission failure is the most common complaint, and some cars lose acceleration without a warning light.

Decided between Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander? Run a VIN check before you buy — uncover hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls.

Look Up a VIN →

How we score the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander

Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

See incorrect data? Report an issue