Last updated: 2026-11-20

Buick vs Toyota: Reliability Compared

Buick and Toyota finish effectively tied on reliability, with Buick a hair ahead. Toyota is cheaper to keep running, while Buick draws fewer recalls. Both brands rate good and both are improving, so the choice comes down to cost, body style, and the specific model.

Is Buick More Reliable Than Toyota?

MetricBuickToyota
Avg Reliability Score76/10075/100
Models Tracked719
Avg Recalls per Model623
Avg Complaints per Model152785
Avg Annual Repair Cost$543/yr$482/yr

Buick Models

7 models ranked by reliability

Excellent Good Mixed Risky

Toyota Models

19 models ranked by reliability

Excellent Good Mixed Risky

Buick vs Toyota: The Verdict

A near tie, with Buick a hair ahead on reliability. Both brands stand good, both are trending up, and owner complaints per car sold are close. Complaint severity is even, and so is the spread of problems across systems.

The deciding differences are small and point in opposite directions. Buick has the edge on recall impact. Toyota has the edge on repair costs, with lower yearly upkeep in independent repair-cost data. Toyota also wins among sedans. In SUVs the two are even.

Where Buick and Toyota Differ Most

ComponentWeightBuickToyota
Complaint Severity

Owner complaints weighted by component severity

35%
68/100Good
67/100Good
Repair Costs

Annual maintenance and repair expenses

30%
73/100Good
77/100Good
Recall Impact

Safety recalls weighted by severity (park-it, park-outside)

20%
90/100Excellent
79/100Good
Issue Diversity

How many different systems have reported problems

15%
82/100Excellent
81/100Excellent

Dig into the components and recall impact stands out — Buick outscores by 11 points there, which carries significant weight in the final number.

Buick vs Toyota: Strengths and Weaknesses

Buick

Strengths

  • Strong overall reliability (76/100 average)
  • Minimal recall impact — fewer safety-critical recalls
  • Focused issue profile — problems concentrated in fewer areas
  • Reasonable maintenance costs ($543/year avg)
  • Reliability trending upward in recent model years
  • 7 of 7 models rated Good or Excellent
  • Below-average repair frequency

Weaknesses

  • Above-average repair severity when issues occur

Toyota

Strengths

  • Strong overall reliability (75/100 average)
  • Minimal recall impact — fewer safety-critical recalls
  • Focused issue profile — problems concentrated in fewer areas
  • Very affordable maintenance ($482/year avg)
  • Reliability trending upward in recent model years
  • 19 of 19 models rated Good or Excellent
  • Below-average repair frequency

Weaknesses

  • 113 fire-related complaints across lineup
  • Above-average repair severity when issues occur

How Reliable Are Buick and Toyota Lineups?

Distribution of model reliability ratings across each make’s lineup:

Buick

Excellent (80+)0 models
Good (60–79)7 models
Mixed (40–59)0 models
Poor (0–39)0 models

Toyota

Excellent (80+)3 models
Good (60–79)16 models
Mixed (40–59)0 models
Poor (0–39)0 models

Which Make Is Cheaper to Maintain: Buick or Toyota?

Based on independent repair cost data, Toyota is cheaper to maintain at an average of $482/year compared to $543/year for Buick. The difference is relatively small, so maintenance costs shouldn't be a major deciding factor between these makes.

Buick Repair Cost Range

$466 – $573/yr

Average: $543/yr

Toyota Repair Cost Range

$362 – $642/yr

Average: $482/yr

Buick vs Toyota Reliability by Vehicle Type

How the two makes compare within each vehicle category they both compete in:

CategoryBuickToyotaWinner
SUVs(5 vs 9 models)77/10076/100Buick
Sedans(2 vs 5 models)74/10078/100Toyota

The makes split categories evenly at 1–1.

Common Problems: Buick vs Toyota

ComponentBuickToyota
POWER TRAIN13%11316%2,065
ENGINE17%15613%1,734
UNKNOWN OR OTHER11%10311%1,457
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM19%17210%1,342
SERVICE BRAKES18%16010%1,343
AIR BAGS4%338%1,050
FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM4%398%1,026
STRUCTURE1%85%694
ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING2%191%99

Share of each make’s complaints, with counts below.

Buick vs Toyota Complaint Severity: Crashes, Fires, and Injuries

Buick

47

Crash reports

5

Fire reports

40

Injury reports

Toyota

902

Crash reports

113

Fire reports

790

Injury reports

Every Buick and Toyota Model Ranked

Buick vs Toyota Reliability Trend by Year

Buick's reliability is improving — recent model years average 80/100, up from earlier years. Toyota's reliability is improving — recent model years average 81/100.

Both makes are trending improving in recent model years — neither is pulling away.

Model YearBuickToyotaEdge
202680/100(4)84/100(13)Toyota
202579/100(4)78/100(15)Buick
202476/100(4)75/100(16)Buick
202378/100(3)74/100(15)Buick
202276/100(4)75/100(16)Buick
202175/100(4)74/100(14)Buick
202073/100(5)74/100(13)Toyota
201975/100(5)71/100(12)Buick
201876/100(5)72/100(12)Buick

Models tracked per year in parentheses.

Buick vs Toyota: Head-to-Head Model Matchups

These are direct competitor models between Buick and Toyota. Click any matchup for a detailed model-vs-model reliability comparison:

Who Should Buy Buick vs Toyota?

If you want the lowest upkeep or a sedan, lean Toyota. The Corolla rates excellent and sits well above other sedans. The Corolla Cross and 4Runner also rate excellent. Skip 2022 and 2023 Tundras, which draw heavy engine complaints, and avoid the 2020 Corolla, where an engine warning that will not clear is the top complaint.

If you want a small SUV and care about a lighter recall record, lean Buick. The Envista is the strongest Buick, and no model year is a poor one. The 2024 is the safest pick. Test the digital instrument panel, which can go black without warning. Encore, Envision, and Encore GX also rate good. Be careful with the Regal. Owners report it surging forward with the brake pedal pressed, and some reports involve crashes. If you buy one, favor 2020 and check the brakes first.

The Bottom Line: Buick or Toyota?

Choose on model, not badge. The Corolla is the strongest car across both lineups, rated excellent with repair costs under the compact average. Toyota also saves money. Its average yearly repair estimate is $61 lower, which comes to about $305 over five years. Buick is a sound pick if you want an SUV like the Envista and can live with slightly higher upkeep.

Buick vs Toyota: Common Questions

Is Buick more reliable than Toyota?
Only by a sliver, and the two are effectively tied. Buick edges ahead, but both stand good and both are trending up. Toyota is stronger on repair costs and sedans, while Buick is stronger on recall impact. The specific model matters more than the badge.
Which brand has more recalls, Buick or Toyota?
Toyota has far more, with 444 recalls against 40 for Buick, according to federal recall records. Toyota also tracks 19 models to Buick's 7, so part of the gap is lineup size. Even so, Buick is rated stronger on recall impact.
Which is cheaper to repair, Buick or Toyota?
Toyota is cheaper. Independent repair-cost data puts Toyota at about $482 a year and Buick at about $543. That gap is $61 a year, or roughly $305 over five years. Cost varies by model, so check the specific car you are considering.
What problems do Buicks have most often?
Owner complaints about Buick center on the electrical system, service brakes, and engine. On the Envista, the digital instrument panel can go black without warning. On the Regal, owners report surging forward with the brake pedal pressed and a false Shift to Park warning that drains the battery.
What problems do Toyotas have most often?
Toyota owners report power train and engine problems most often, followed by electrical complaints. On the Tundra, 2022 and 2023 draw heavy engine complaints, and fuel pump failures can stall the truck. The 2020 Corolla is known for an engine warning that will not clear.

Comparing Buick vs Toyota? Run a VIN check on any specific vehicle before you buy — uncover hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls.

Look Up a VIN →

Related Make Comparisons

How we score Buick and Toyota models

Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.