Last updated: 2026-11-19

2020 Tesla Model Y
45
MixedReliability score: 45 out of 100, rated Mixed

Reliability score

Mixed · #5 of 6 scored Model Y years

2020 Tesla Model Y Reliability Report

The 2020 Tesla Model Y rates mixed and well below other 2020 SUVs, mainly because of phantom braking and early front suspension wear.

Recalls

24

Complaints

285

Complaint Rate

71.2per 10,000 sold

Est. Repair Cost

$832

EV Range

291–316 mi

Detailed Score Breakdown

Complaint Severity35% of score41/100

Component-weighted complaints normalized by sales volume

Repair Costs30% of score40/100

Independent repair cost ratings

Recall Impact20% of score42/100

Recall count weighted by severity

Issue Diversity15% of score69/100

Breadth of reported problem categories

The verdict

Caution

First year of the generation, marked by phantom braking, low-speed surges, and early front suspension wear; the 2021 rates about the same.

Looking at a used 2020 Tesla Model Y? Check that exact car

24 recalls cover this year. A VIN check shows whether the car you found had the work done, plus accidents, title and odometer history.

Generation & Refresh (US)

Redesign Year

2020 is the first model year of the First generation.

  • First-year models may have unresolved issues from the new design.
  • Redesigned for the 2020 model year.
  • Refreshed in 2025.
  • 1st generation Model Y (US).

What this means for buyers

First-year models carry more risk — early production issues are common. Consider waiting for the second year if reliability is a priority.

Compare 2020 pricing and recall counts against 2021+ before deciding.

2020: First generation Launch

Generation start — new platform.

2025: Mid-Cycle Refresh

Updated features and styling tweaks.

Should You Buy the 2020 Tesla Model Y?

Mixed is the fair verdict. Against other 2020 SUVs this Model Y sits well below average, and it is among the weaker of the six Model Y years scored. It is the first year of its generation. The 2021 rates about the same, so moving up a year does not clearly fix anything.

Phantom braking leads the complaints. With Autopilot, adaptive cruise, or Full Self-Driving on, owners say the car drops 5 to 10 mph on clear highways and following drivers swerve. Others describe low-speed surges in parking lots and driveways that end in crashes. Front control arms and links wear too, with torn parts found between 31,099 and 39,000 miles. In the worst reports a front knuckle separates and steering is lost. Federal records list 24 recalls, including suspension, steering, and service brakes.

Ask for proof that every recall was completed, and have the front suspension inspected. Test cruise control on a highway before signing.

Compared to the 2021 Tesla Model Y, which scored the same.

Pros

  • 5-star NHTSA crash rating

Cons

  • Below-average reliability score
  • Above-average recall count
  • Above-average complaint rate for SUV
  • Automatic emergency brakingSudden hard braking with nothing ahead is the dominant report62 complaints

Compare 2020 Tesla Model Y With

Recall Overview

24

recalls on record

The 2020 Tesla Model Y has 24 recalls on record, which is above average. A high count can flag multiple component concerns, though it also shows the manufacturer is actively addressing known issues.

NHTSA.gov →

Complaint Breakdown

71.2

per 10,000 sold

Segment avg: 24.4

LowAvgHigh
High

Safety Incidents

48

Crashes

0

Fires

26

Injuries

0

Deaths

★★★★★

NHTSA 5/5 Stars

Data sourced from NHTSA complaint filings and manufacturer recall notices. Complaint narratives are owner-reported.

2020 Tesla Model Y Recall Details

24 recalls have been issued for the 2020 Tesla Model Y. Recall repairs are free at authorized dealers, so check that each one below was done on the car you are looking at.

Headlights and exterior lightsRecall 20V609000Sep 30, 2020

A software error prevents the illumination of trailer brake lights.

As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard number 108, "Lamps, Reflective Devices, and Associated Equipment."

Risk
Trailer brake lights that fail to illuminate during braking increase the risk of a crash.
Fix
Tesla will notify owners, and has released the firmware update over-the-air (OTA) to vehicles as of September 23, 2020.
Which vehicles are covered

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2020 Model Y vehicles equipped with a global rear lamp and tow package configuration.

More about the fix

Owners may contact Tesla customer service at 1-877-798-3752. Tesla's number for this recall is SB-20-00-002.

SuspensionRecall 20V709000Nov 17, 2020

The bolts connecting the front upper control arm and steering knuckle may have not been properly tightened, allowing the upper control arm to detach from the steering knuckle.

Risk
A detached upper control arm can cause the wheels to lean in or out, decreasing the driver's ability to steer and increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix
Tesla will notify owners, and dealers will inspect, and as necessary, tighten the bolts, free of charge.
Which vehicles are covered

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2020 Model Y vehicles.

More about the fix

The recall began January 15, 2021. Owners may contact Tesla customer service at 1-877-798-3752. Tesla's number for this recall is SB-20-31-012.

BrakesRecall 21V387000May 25, 2021

The brake caliper bolts may be loose, allowing the brake caliper to separate and contact the wheel rim.

Risk
Contact with the rim may cause a loss of tire pressure, increasing the risk of a crash.
Fix
Tesla Service will inspect and tighten, or replace the caliper bolts as necessary, free of charge.
Which vehicles are covered

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2019-2021 Model 3 and 2020-2021 Model Y vehicles.

More about the fix

Owner notification letters were mailed July 23, 2021. Owners may contact Tesla customer service online by visiting www.tesla.com/support/contact or by calling 1-877-79-TESLA (or 1-877-798-3752). Tesla's number for this recall is SB-21-33-002.

Showing 10 of 24 recalls. View all on NHTSA.gov →

VIN History Report

24 recalls and a score of 45 — check any 2020 Tesla Model Y before buying

With a below-average reliability score, a VIN check is especially important. Uncover hidden accidents, title problems, odometer rollbacks, and open recalls that data alone can't show you.

No VIN? Just hit “Check VIN” to look one up.

  • Accidents
  • Open Recalls
  • Title History
  • Odometer Rollback

2020 Tesla Model Y NHTSA Safety Ratings

Overall Safety Rating

Overall safety rating: 5 out of 5
Crash Test Results by Configuration (expand)

Gas Powertrain

Driver: 5/5Passenger: 5/5

Rollover risk: 7.9%

Safety Technologies

Dynamic Head Restraints (Not Available)Head Restraint (Not Available)Advanced Belt Feature (Standard)Adjustable Upper Belt Anchorage (Driver, Front Passenger)Seat Belt Reminder System (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat)Frontal Air Bag (Driver, Front Passenger)Curtain (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat)Torso/Pelvis (Driver, Front Passenger)Knee (Driver, Front Passenger)Additional Air Bags (Not Available)Meets Side Air Bag Out-of-Position Requirements (Yes)LATCH Locations (Rear Seat)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) (Standard)Safety Power Windows (Anti-Pinch) locations (Driver, Front Passenger, Rear Seat)
View full safety data on NHTSA.gov →

Tesla Model Y Repair Costs & Maintenance

Maintenance Rating

2Maintenance rating: 2 out of 5

Based on NHTSA complaint patterns, recall severity, and publicly available cost benchmarks.

Est. Annual Maintenance

$832

Category-level averages derived from publicly available industry reports (AAA, CarMD). Model-level estimates produced by Auto Reliability Index.

Tesla Model Y Resale Value

The Tesla Model Y is estimated to retain about 48.4% of its original value after 5 years, based on observed used-car listings.

This benchmark covers the Tesla Model Y model overall and is not specific to the 2020 model year.

Value Retained
48.4%

after 5 years

Depreciation
51.6%

over the same period

Listings Analyzed
420

U.S. used-car listings

Listings observed in . Actual resale value varies by trim, mileage, condition, and location.

Explore Tesla Model Y depreciation and resale value on CarResaleValue.com

2020 Tesla Model Y Example Repair Prices

National average price ranges for common repairs. These are not model-year-specific failure predictions.

Common repair costs and price estimates
RepairEstimated Cost
Engine Oil Light Diagnosis$122 – $179
Air Conditioning System Leak Inspection$122 – $179
Pre-Purchase Car Inspection$183 – $269
Check Engine Light Diagnosis & Testing$122 – $179
Engine Oil Light Diagnosis$122 – $179
Vibration Diagnosis$122 – $179
Pre-Purchase Car Inspection$183 – $269
Noise Diagnosis$122 – $179
Tire Pressure Monitor Lamp Diagnosis$122 – $179
AC Diagnosis$122 – $179

Estimates based on national average repair costs. Actual costs may vary by location and shop.

MPG & Annual Running Costs

Electric

291–316 mi range

Fuel cost: $650–$700/yr

Fuel only

27.856–30.353 kWh/100mi · 10 hrs @ 240V

Based on EPA fuel-cost estimates. Excludes routine maintenance, depreciation, and insurance. Data as of 2020 EPA label cycle.

Electric trims
TrimDriveTrans.RangekWh/100miFuel Cost
Model Y Long Range AWDAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (A1)316 mi27.9$650
Model Y Performance AWDAll-Wheel DriveAutomatic (A1)315 mi28.0$650
Model Y Performance AWD (21in Wheels)All-Wheel DriveAutomatic (A1)291 mi30.4$700

Used Buying Checklist

Key things to inspect or verify before purchasing a 2020 Tesla Model Y.

  • Drive at least 20 minutes on a highway with cruise control on and note any hard braking with no traffic ahead.

  • Turn the wheel fully each way while rolling slowly and listen for clicking, creaking, or rattling from the front suspension.

  • Check the inner edges of all four tires for uneven wear and ask for records of control arm or link repairs.

  • Seat an adult in the front passenger seat and watch for a passenger restraint system fault or airbag-off light.

  • Open each rear door from inside and outside several times to confirm none sticks shut.

  • At night, switch on each turn signal and check the side camera view for red haze or glare.

  • Charge to 100 percent and confirm the car accepts Level 2 charging and shows reasonable range.

  • On the test drive, watch for touchscreen freezes, reboots, slow backup camera loading, or any steering assist warning.

Going to see one? Take the printable 2020 Tesla Model Y inspection checklist with you.

2020 Tesla Model Y Common Problems by Component

285 owner complaints grouped by vehicle system.

62
35
29
61
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE (62)UNKNOWN OR OTHER (35)SERVICE BRAKES (29)SUSPENSION (23)VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL (23)ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (22)STEERING (16)AIR BAGS (14)Other (61)

FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE

62 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y automatic emergency braking problems across all model years

Sudden hard braking with nothing ahead is the dominant report. With Autopilot, adaptive cruise, or Full Self-Driving engaged, the car sheds 5-10 mph on clear, open highways, and following drivers have to swerve. Several reports say it started or got worse after software updates, and many drivers give up on cruise control. A smaller group of crash reports describes the car lurching forward from a stop, swerving out of its lane, or failing to brake for a vehicle ahead. Seven of the 62 filings involve a crash.

62 complaints total7 crashes2 injuries

UNKNOWN OR OTHER

35 complaintsSafety-related

Unintended acceleration while parking or stopped is the most serious theme. Cars lunge into poles, trucks, signs, and parked vehicles, and drivers say braking did not stop them. Other reports cover a touchscreen that freezes and hides gear and speed, a backup camera that fails to load or lags, and a power liftgate that keeps moving after hitting a person or a garage door. Single reports mention a hood latch failing on the highway, spins on snow under regenerative braking, and a heating failure left unfixed because parts were unavailable.

35 complaints total6 crashes1 injury

SERVICE BRAKES

29 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y brake problems across all model years

Phantom braking dominates here too. On Autopilot, cruise control, or Full Self-Driving, the car brakes hard at highway speed with no obstacle, sometimes many times on one trip, and nearly causes rear-end collisions. One sudden stop injured a pet riding in the back seat. The crash reports are different. Drivers say the car surged in parking lots and did not respond to the brake pedal, and one saw an "Automatic braking disabled" warning. Another describes traction and stability control shutting off before the car spun. One owner says Tesla promised a future software fix.

29 complaints total5 crashes6 injuries
SUSPENSION (23 complaints)

SUSPENSION

23 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y suspension problems across all model years

Front control arms and lateral links wear out. The first sign is creaking, clicking, or rattling when turning or backing up. Owners report torn links and bushings found at service between 31,099 and 39,000 miles. Others find loose or missing suspension bolts, a rear shimmy over bumps, and fast wear on the inner edges of the tires. In the worst reports a front knuckle separates and the driver loses steering. Many filings come from one person posting salvage-auction photos of broken hubs. That person did not own the cars.

23 complaints total2 crashes1 injury
VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL (23 complaints)

VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL

23 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y acceleration and cruise control problems across all model years

Low-speed surges cause the crashes in this category. The car accelerates on its own while pulling into parking spaces or driveways, or while reversing, and does not stop promptly when braked. Cars hit parked vehicles, garages, and a house, and one driver suffered a fractured neck. Separate reports describe phantom braking from highway speed on adaptive cruise, a frozen touchscreen that hides speed and gear, and camera faults that quietly degrade cruise control. One owner says Tesla pointed to the Autopilot computer needing replacement.

23 complaints total5 crashes6 injuries
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (22 complaints)

ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

22 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y electrical problems across all model years

Sudden shutdowns and frozen screens lead the reports. While the car is moving, the display freezes or goes black and the driver loses speed, gear, and turn signals for several minutes. Some cars lose drive power with only seconds of warning, and one stall was fixed with a new rear drive inverter. Higher-mileage owners report steep range loss, and one car stopped accepting Level 2 charging at 46,000 miles. In one case the 12-volt battery died without warning and left a toddler locked inside.

22 complaints total3 crashes1 injury
STEERING (16 complaints)

STEERING

16 complaintsSafety-related

Model Y steering problems across all model years

Power steering assist cuts out and the wheel becomes very hard to turn, often after a "Steering assist reduced" warning. Drivers report it happening mid-turn and while merging on the freeway. One owner at 54k miles was quoted 3k for a steering rack. Another paid $990 to repair rodent damage to the rack wiring harness. Autosteer also jerks the car toward neighboring lanes, and clicking control arms lead to paid repairs. Several filings here describe other vehicles or come from one person citing salvage photos.

16 complaints total4 crashes2 injuries
AIR BAGS (14 complaints)

AIR BAGS

14 complaintsSafety-related

Airbags fail to deploy in serious crashes. Reports include a head-on collision and impacts with a building, a dumpster, and a concrete median, with occupants suffering fractures and head injuries. The more common problem is a recurring front passenger restraint fault, code RCM2_A636, that turns off the passenger airbag. The fault comes and goes. Repairs usually mean a new sensor or seat, quotes run from about $1100 to $2000 once the warranty ends, and some fixes do not last.

14 complaints total6 crashes5 injuries
STRUCTURE (12 complaints)

STRUCTURE

12 complaintsSafety-related

Rear doors jam shut when an interior panel slips off its clips and wedges against the seal. Back-seat passengers cannot get out until a technician pries the door free, and some owners have had it happen repeatedly. The manual release for the rear doors sits under a mat and a cover, and one owner says it takes a screwdriver to reach. Other reports describe the power liftgate closing on fingers and a broken frunk weld. The crash reports describe sudden acceleration into garages and parking-lot obstacles in nearly new cars.

12 complaints total4 crashes1 injury
LANE DEPARTURE (8 complaints)

LANE DEPARTURE

8 complaintsSafety-related

At night, the side cameras show a red haze or glare whenever the turn signal is on, because light from the signal leaks into the camera. The blind-spot view becomes hard or impossible to use, and owners worry about lane keeping because the driver-assist system relies only on cameras. Other reports describe Full Self-Driving steering toward closed highway ramps, the car losing control in heavy rain on Autopilot, and driver aids failing after a software update. One owner was quoted $2,666.96 to restore them.

8 complaints total2 crashes1 injury

When Do 2020 Tesla Model Y Problems Start?

Based on owner complaint patterns, here’s when common issues tend to appear.

31,099–39,000 milesFront control arm and link wear
51,126–59,127 milesSevere battery range loss

Best & Worst Tesla Model Y Years

Tesla Model Y reliability score trend

Scores 0–100, higher is better. Best and worst years are ringed. This year is highlighted.

Tesla Model Y reliability scores by year
YearScoreRating
202045/100Mixed
202145/100Mixed
202249/100Mixed
202351/100Mixed
202462/100Good
202568/100Good

Tesla Model Y Reliability Compared to Other Years

Reliability scores compared across model years
YearScorevs Prior YearRatingRecallsComplaints
202568/100+6Good3117
202462/100+11Good5340
202351/100+2Mixed171201
202249/100+4Mixed20886
202145/1000Mixed231105
2020(selected)45/100—Mixed24285

2020 Tesla Model Y Common Questions

2 questions from 2020 Tesla Model Y owners.

wipers are not working

Can you tell me if you can switch the 3 antennas in your old side mirrors to your new side mirrors that don't come with them?

2018 Tesla model 3 Can you tell me if you can switch the 3 antennas in your old side mirrors to your new side mirrors that don't come with them? Comes with blue connector but not the 2 antenna connectors in the RH mirror and the 1 antennas connector in the LH mirror. Wanting to use these antennas on new mirror. Are they easy to switch to new mirrors that do not come with the antennas?

VisitorAug 7, 2024

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 2020 Tesla Model Y reliable?
Not very. Its reliability standing is mixed, and it ranks well below average among 2020 SUVs. Within the Model Y lineup it is among the weaker of six scored years. It earns 5 of 5 stars in the federal crash test, but owner complaints and recalls point to braking and suspension trouble.
What are the most common problems with the 2020 Tesla Model Y?
Forward collision avoidance is the biggest category, with 62 complaints, mostly sudden hard braking on open highways. Service brakes draw 29 complaints, vehicle speed control 23, and suspension 23. Suspension reports cover worn front control arms and links. Some suspension filings come from one person posting salvage-auction photos, not from an owner.
Does the 2020 Tesla Model Y have phantom braking problems?
Yes, it is the dominant complaint. With Autopilot, adaptive cruise, or Full Self-Driving engaged, owners say the car brakes hard with nothing ahead, often losing 5 to 10 mph. Some report it many times on one trip. Several say it began or worsened after software updates, and many stopped using cruise control.
Does the 2020 Tesla Model Y have suspension problems?
Yes. Owners report front control arms and lateral links wearing out, first as creaking, clicking, or rattling when turning or backing up. Torn links and bushings were found at service between 31,099 and 39,000 miles. Some owners found loose or missing bolts. In the worst reports a front knuckle separated and the driver lost steering.
How many recalls does the 2020 Tesla Model Y have?
Federal records list 24 recalls. Areas include exterior lighting, suspension, seat belts, steering, service brakes, forward collision avoidance, tires, latches, and back over prevention. Several involve the electrical system. The 2021 has 23 recalls, so the count does not separate the two years. Ask the seller for proof each repair was done.

Don’t buy a 2020 Tesla Model Y without checking its VIN first — hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls could cost you thousands.

Look Up a VIN →

How we score the 2020 Tesla Model Y

Of the four inputs behind this score, the 2020 Tesla Model Y does best on how many systems draw complaints (69/100) and worst on repair costs (40/100). Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

Get notified when new recalls or reliability data is added for the Tesla Model Y.

No spam. Only data updates for this model.

See incorrect data? Report an issue