Last updated: 2026-11-19

Tesla Model Y

Tesla Model Y Years to Avoid

6 scored model years (2020–2025) · model average 53/100

Skip the 2020 and 2021 Model Y. Both sit well below the model's own average, mainly because of phantom braking and cars surging at parking-lot speeds. The 2024 is the better used buy, with far fewer recalls and complaints.

Verdict

Avoid
2021 45/1002020 45/100
Buy
2024 62/100
Model average
53/100

Know which year you're looking at? Check the exact Tesla Model Y

A good year can still hide accident damage or recall work that was never done. A VIN check shows the history of the car you found.

Tesla Model Y Years to Avoid

These model years score significantly below the Tesla Model Y average of 53/100.

#YearScoreRatingRecallsComplaintsTop Issue
1202145/100Mixed231105Forward Collision Avoidance (338)
2202045/100Mixed24285Forward Collision Avoidance (62)

Why These Years Should Be Avoided

45
MixedReliability score: 45 out of 100, rated Mixed

2021 Tesla Model Y

Owners filed 1105 complaints. Drivers describe the wheel jerking toward a median under Autopilot and hard braking with nothing ahead. Others say the car accelerated at parking speeds while the brake did nothing, ending in crashes into trees, buildings, and other cars, often with airbag deployment.

23 recalls1105 complaintsEst. repair:

Top issues: Forward Collision Avoidance (338), Service Brakes (151), Vehicle Speed Control (106), Electrical System (103), Unknown Or Other (95), Steering (62)

View full 2021 reliability report →
45
MixedReliability score: 45 out of 100, rated Mixed

2020 Tesla Model Y

Owners describe sudden hard braking on clear highways with Autopilot or cruise control on, shedding 5-10 mph while drivers behind swerve. Others report the car surging in parking lots and ignoring the brake pedal. This year also carries 24 recalls, the most of any year tracked.

24 recalls285 complaintsEst. repair:

Top issues: Forward Collision Avoidance (62), Unknown Or Other (35), Service Brakes (29), Suspension (23), Vehicle Speed Control (23), Electrical System (22)

View full 2020 reliability report →

What Are Common Tesla Model Y Problems?

Most reported in 2021, 2022, 2023

2021: Phantom braking and sudden steering inputs while Autopilot, Full Self-Driving, or lane assist is active dominate these reports.

Most reported in 2021, 2023, 2022

2021: Hard braking at highway speed with nothing ahead is a recurring complaint, and occupants describe being thrown against their seat belts.

Most reported in 2021, 2023, 2022

2021: Sudden loss of power is the most serious pattern.

UNKNOWN OR OTHER

359 complaints

Most reported in 2023, 2021, 2022

2023: This catch-all category is mostly more unintended acceleration and self-driving faults.

Most reported in 2023, 2021, 2022

2023: Sudden unintended acceleration makes up most of this category.

Most reported in 2023, 2021, 2022

2023: Cars pull hard to one side on their own while the wheel locks, stiffens, or stops responding to the driver.

Best Tesla Model Y Year to Buy Instead

62
GoodReliability score: 62 out of 100, rated Good

2024 Tesla Model Y

The 2024 has 5 recalls, against 23 for the 2021 and 24 for the 2020. Its complaint rate per 10,000 sold is also a fraction of theirs. It still has phantom braking and some failed autopilot computers, but the surge-and-crash reports that mark the early years are far less common.

Score: 62/100 (Good)5 recalls340 complaints
View full 2024 reliability report →
VIN History Report

Found a Safe Year? Check the Specific Car

Even the 2024 Tesla Model Y has 5 recalls on file. A VIN check confirms the recall work on the exact car and shows its accident, title, and service history.

No VIN? Just hit “Check VIN” to look one up.

  • Accidents
  • Open Recalls
  • Title History
  • Odometer Rollback

All Tesla Model Y Years by Generation

Tesla Model Y Reliability Scores by Year

Excellent Good Mixed Risky

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Tesla Model Y years should I avoid?
Avoid 2020 and 2021. Both sit well below the model's own average. Owners report phantom braking on highways and cars surging at parking speeds without responding to the brake pedal. The 2020 has 24 recalls and the 2021 has 23.
Is the 2024 Tesla Model Y a safe used buy?
It is the best-supported choice. The 2024 has 5 recalls and a much lower complaint rate than the early years. It is not problem-free. Owners still report phantom braking and autopilot computer failures that disable cameras and emergency braking.
Should I buy a 2025 Tesla Model Y instead?
The 2025 has few complaints and recalls, but it is too new to judge. Problems pile up the longer a model year is on the road. The 2024 is the safer pick because it has had more time to show its record.
Are the 2022 and 2023 Model Y years a good middle option?
They sit between the weak and strong years, but they are not clean. The 2022 has 20 recalls and the 2023 has 17. Phantom braking leads both, and 2023 also has many steering complaints. The 2024 is the better buy.
Is phantom braking fixed in newer Model Y years?
Not entirely. Phantom braking leads complaints in every year tracked, including 2024. Owners say it happens on highways under adaptive cruise or Full Self-Driving, and repeated service visits did not stop it. Complaint volume is lower in newer years.

How we score every Tesla Model Y model year

Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

See incorrect data? Report an issue