Buy with caution. Reliability for this model year is mixed, and it sits well below average among 2019 SUVs. It is also the weakest of the nine scored X5 years. The 2018 and 2020 models both rate better, and the 2018 has far fewer complaints and recalls. Estimated yearly repair cost is $1,166, a little above the $1,127 class figure.
Owners report starter failure first. The car won't start, sometimes with a burning smell, and one complaint describes a starter that smoked and burned. Around 70,000 to 85,000 miles, the oil pump can fail. Owners see sudden low oil pressure warnings, and some needed a new engine. There is no dipstick, so a bad oil reading leaves you unable to check the level. The brake complaints are the most serious. Some owners say the pedal had little effect, and four complaints involve a crash. Cold-weather steering wander is also common. This year has 13 federal recalls, including service brakes, steering, air bags and fuel system.
Ask for proof that every recall was completed. Request records for the starter, oil pump and brake module. Compare the 2018 and 2020 before you commit.