Mixed is the fair verdict. This model year sits well below average among 2018 SUVs and lands in the middle of the nine scored X5 years. The 2019 is also mixed and rates worse, with more complaints and recalls, so moving up a year does not fix much. Repair costs run a little above the class norm. The crash-test rating is 5 of 5 stars.
Cooling and fuel problems stand out. Owners report cracked intake manifolds and failed EGR coolers around 69,000 to 74,000 miles, with black or white smoke and low coolant warnings. Some cars shut down at speed, with sudden stalls or power loss reported at 57,000 to 61,000 miles. Diesel cars see EGR cooler failures return after dealer repairs. The xDrive40e plug-in hybrid can lose all power when its electric motor electronics fail, and one dealer quoted almost $20,000 for the unit. Six recalls cover suspension, engine cooling, electrical, fuel and equipment. Many owners wait months because parts are not available.
Before buying, ask for proof that every recall repair was completed, especially the fuel system, coolant pump and EGR cooler work. Ask whether the EGR cooler or high-pressure fuel pump was replaced before. Be most careful with the diesel and plug-in hybrid versions.