Is the BMW 5-Series more reliable than the Lexus ES?

No. The Lexus ES holds a large reliability lead. It has far fewer recalls, 15 against 54 across eight model years. The 5-Series has coolant leaks, fire reports, and sudden power loss in its owner complaints, while the ES complaints center on stalling and automatic braking.

Which has more recalls, the 5-Series or the ES?

The 5-Series has more. Federal recall records list 54 recalls across its eight model years from 2018 to 2026. The ES has 15 across its eight model years from 2018 to 2025. That is a gap of nearly four to one.

What is the most common engine problem on the BMW 5-Series?

Coolant loss. The plastic oil filter housing cracks around 50-60k miles and dumps coolant. Owners say the low-coolant warning comes on only when the tank is nearly empty, which risks overheating. Dealer quotes reach almost 3,500. Coolant pumps, radiators, and hoses also leak.

Does the Lexus ES have stalling problems?

Yes, some owners report it. Drivers describe no response from the gas pedal at a stop or while merging, then a sudden lunge. Most reports tie this to a low-pressure fuel pump, and owners say dealers had no parts or remedy for months.

Which 5-Series and ES model years should I avoid?

Avoid 2018 and 2019 on both cars, since those are the weakest years for each. The best ES years are 2021 and 2022. The 5-Series ranks best in 2025 and 2026, but those are recent years with less time to collect complaints.

Last updated: 2026-10-10

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES: Reliability Compared

BMW 5 Series

Good

More Reliable

Lexus ES

Excellent

Lexus ES comes out well ahead of BMW 5-Series on reliability. Federal recall records show 15 recalls for the ES across eight model years against 54 for the 5-Series, and the BMW's owner complaints describe more serious failures.

How Do the BMW 5 Series and Lexus ES Generations Compare?

Each car's weakest years come from the older or earliest builds of its current design. The BMW's seventh generation (G30) ran from 2017 to 2023 with a facelift for 2020, so the weak 2018 and 2019 cars are early, pre-facelift builds. The eighth generation (G60) began in 2024, which makes 2024 and later cars a newer design with a shorter complaint history. The ES moved from the sixth generation (XV60) to the seventh generation (XZ10) in 2019. A facelift followed for 2021, so its strongest years, 2021 and 2022, are facelifted cars. Its 2018 car is the older design, and 2019 is the first year of the new one.

Verdict

The Lexus ES is more reliable than the BMW 5 Series, scoring 83/100 vs 67/100.

Reliability favors the Lexus ES by a large margin. Federal recall records show 54 recalls across eight BMW 5-Series model years, against 15 for the ES. The BMW's owner complaints also describe more alarming failures: cracked oil filter housings dumping coolant, defroster wiring fires, and sudden loss of power at highway speed. The ES has its own stalling and braking complaints, but its recall count is far lower and its reports are less varied.

Key Differences

1Lexus ES has 39 fewer total recalls
2Lexus ES scores 16 points higher in reliability

Category Scoreboard

0BMW 5 Series

—

2Lexus ES

Reliability ScoreTotal Recalls

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES: Which Is More Reliable?

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES at-a-glance reliability comparison
Metric	BMW 5 Series	Lexus ES
Reliability Score	67/100	83/100
Years Tracked	8	8
Total Recalls	54	15
Total ComplaintsRaw count — varies with sales volume	330	95
Year Wins	0	7

What Are the Common Problems With the BMW 5 Series and Lexus ES?

The BMW's complaints spread across many systems. A cracked plastic oil filter housing dumps coolant, and two reports describe engine fires. Defroster wiring is behind both electrical fire reports. Some cars lose power at 50-60 mph with "Reduced Power" messages, and false passenger restraint warnings often end in a seat sensor mat quoted at $2000 to $2800. The ES centers on stalling and weak throttle response, mostly tied to a low-pressure fuel pump, plus automatic braking that fires on its own. Crash-linked service brake complaints appear only on the ES. Crash-linked power train and seat belt complaints appear only on the BMW. Air bag and electrical complaints include crashes on both.

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES common problem areas comparison
Component	BMW 5 Series	Lexus ES
AIR BAGS	45	8
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM	33	4
UNKNOWN OR OTHER	31	6
ENGINE	23	6
POWER TRAIN	17	3
FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM	8	7
SERVICE BRAKES	9	5
SEAT BELTS	11	—
FUEL SYSTEM	7	3
VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL	7	2
EXTERIOR LIGHTING	6	—
BACK OVER PREVENTION	4	—
STRUCTURE	2	2
WHEELS	2	2
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE	2	—
LANE DEPARTURE	—	2
TIRES	—	2

Raw complaint counts aggregated across all tracked model years from NHTSA owner reports. Counts vary with sales volume.

How Does BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES Reliability Compare by Year?

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES year-by-year reliability scores
Year	BMW 5 Series	Lexus ES	Edge
2025	71/1005R / 0C	83/1001R / 4C	Lexus ES
2023	70/1002R / 7C	80/1004R / 18C	Lexus ES
2022	68/1003R / 13C	88/1000R / 16C	Lexus ES
2021	66/1008R / 21C	88/1000R / 0C	Lexus ES
2020	67/1007R / 10C	83/1001R / 5C	Lexus ES
2019	62/10011R / 67C	78/1003R / 33C	Lexus ES
2018	59/10017R / 212C	80/1002R / 10C	Lexus ES

Best years to cross-shop: The 2023 BMW 5 Series scored 70/100 and the 2022 Lexus ES scored 88/100 — the strongest shared model years that have been on the road for at least two years, where available.

Who Should Buy the BMW 5 Series vs the Lexus ES?

If you want the lower-risk sedan, buy the ES. Target 2021 or 2022, its strongest years, and avoid 2018 and 2019, its weakest. Know the weak spots going in. Stalling tied to the low-pressure fuel pump left some owners waiting months for parts, and automatic emergency braking has braked hard on its own. Confirm with the seller that every open recall was completed. Choose the 5-Series only if you accept more risk and can verify the car's history. Skip 2018 and 2019, the weakest years. The 2025 and 2026 cars rank strongest, but they are recent and have had less time to collect complaints, so do not treat that as proof. Have the oil filter housing, coolant system, passenger seat sensor, and rear defroster wiring inspected. Avoid a 530e unless the high-voltage battery warranty terms are clear, since owners report disputed replacements.

BMW 5 Series vs Lexus ES: Common Questions

Is the BMW 5-Series more reliable than the Lexus ES?: No. The Lexus ES holds a large reliability lead. It has far fewer recalls, 15 against 54 across eight model years. The 5-Series has coolant leaks, fire reports, and sudden power loss in its owner complaints, while the ES complaints center on stalling and automatic braking.
Which has more recalls, the 5-Series or the ES?: The 5-Series has more. Federal recall records list 54 recalls across its eight model years from 2018 to 2026. The ES has 15 across its eight model years from 2018 to 2025. That is a gap of nearly four to one.
What is the most common engine problem on the BMW 5-Series?: Coolant loss. The plastic oil filter housing cracks around 50-60k miles and dumps coolant. Owners say the low-coolant warning comes on only when the tank is nearly empty, which risks overheating. Dealer quotes reach almost 3,500. Coolant pumps, radiators, and hoses also leak.
Does the Lexus ES have stalling problems?: Yes, some owners report it. Drivers describe no response from the gas pedal at a stop or while merging, then a sudden lunge. Most reports tie this to a low-pressure fuel pump, and owners say dealers had no parts or remedy for months.
Which 5-Series and ES model years should I avoid?: Avoid 2018 and 2019 on both cars, since those are the weakest years for each. The best ES years are 2021 and 2022. The 5-Series ranks best in 2025 and 2026, but those are recent years with less time to collect complaints.

More BMW 5 Series comparisons

BMW 5 Series vs Volvo S90 reliability BMW 5 Series vs Land Rover Range Rover Sport reliability BMW 5 Series vs Volvo S60 reliability BMW 5 Series reliability by year BMW 5 Series years to avoid

More Lexus ES comparisons

Lexus ES vs Mercedes-Benz E-Class reliability Lexus ES vs Acura TLX reliability Lexus ES vs Volvo S60 reliability Lexus ES vs Tesla Model 3 reliability Lexus ES reliability by year Lexus ES years to avoid

Decided between BMW 5 Series and Lexus ES? Run a VIN check before you buy — uncover hidden accidents, title issues, and open recalls.

Look Up a VIN →

How we score the BMW 5 Series and Lexus ES

Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.

See incorrect data? Report an issue