Last updated: 2026-11-19

BMW i5 Years to Avoid
2 scored model years (2024–2025) · model average 65/100
No i5 model year is one to avoid. Both years rate well. What changes is the type of complaint: 2024 reports center on electrical and charging trouble, while 2025 reports lean toward brakes and drive power. Of the two, 2024 is the year to buy.
Verdict
- Avoid
- No outlier years
- Buy
- 2024 63/100
- Model average
- 65/100
Know which year you're looking at? Check the exact BMW i5
A good year can still hide accident damage or recall work that was never done. A VIN check shows the history of the car you found.
What Are Common BMW i5 Problems?
SERVICE BRAKES
6 complaintsMost reported in 2025, 2024
2025: Braking fails at low speed in these reports.
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
5 complaintsMost reported in 2024
2024: The most common complaint is loud fan noise, clunking and banging during and after DC fast charging, sometimes with a battery temperature warning.
POWER TRAIN
4 complaintsMost reported in 2025, 2024
2025: The drivetrain shuts down while the car is moving.
UNKNOWN OR OTHER
4 complaintsMost reported in 2025, 2024
2025: A sunroof shatters at highway speed, with glass falling into the cabin and no sign of a rock strike.
ELECTRONIC STABILITY CONTROL (ESC)
4 complaintsMost reported in 2024
2024: Most of these reports are about a recall repair that cannot be done because the part is unavailable.
BACK OVER PREVENTION
2 complaintsMost reported in 2024
2024: While reversing, the central display can black out for 3 to 5 seconds, wiping out the rear camera image without warning and forcing hard braking near people or objects.
Best BMW i5 Year to Buy Instead
2024 BMW i5
2024 has the longer track record, and neither year rates as weak, so its fuller history makes it the safer pick. Its most common complaints are fan noise and clunking around DC fast charging, plus recall repairs waiting on parts. 2025 shows fewer complaints so far, but it has had less time to collect them, so that lower count does not prove it is the better car.
Found a Safe Year? Check the Specific Car
Even the 2024 BMW i5 has 10 recalls on file. A VIN check confirms the recall work on the exact car and shows its accident, title, and service history.
- Accidents
- Open Recalls
- Title History
- Odometer Rollback
All BMW i5 Years by Generation
BMW i5 Reliability Scores by Year
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there any BMW i5 years to avoid?
Which BMW i5 years have brake problems?
Which BMW i5 years lose drive power?
Should I buy a 2024 or 2025 BMW i5?
Which BMW i5 year has charging problems?
How we score every BMW i5 model year
Scores weight complaint severity at 35%, repair costs at 30%, recall impact at 20%, and the spread of complaints across systems at 15%, with complaint counts adjusted for US sales. Read the full methodology.
See incorrect data? Report an issue