Last updated: 2026-11-19

Engine & powertrain

Kia Soul Transmission Problems

Kia Soul transmission trouble mostly means sudden power loss with surging RPMs, worst in the 2020 model year, often at highway speed.

Kia Soul
Owner complaints
104
Share of all complaints
9%
Crash / fire / injury reports
3 / 0 / 3
Related recalls
2

Kia Soul transmission complaints by model year

The 2020 model year leads by a wide margin, with 60 of the 104 transmission complaints and the highest rate per vehicles sold. The 2018 and 2021 years sit in the middle, and 2021 owners describe the same power-loss failures. The 2019, 2022 and 2023 years have few complaints, though 2022 owners report very early failures. The 2024 and 2025 years have none, but they are recent and have had little time to collect filings, so that does not make them better choices.

Most complaints Other yearsRate = complaints per 10,000 sold
Kia Soul transmission complaints by model year
Model yearComplaintsPer 10,000 soldCrash, fire, injury reports
2018171.61, 0, 0
201920.20, 0, 0
2020608.41, 0, 1
20211521, 0, 0
202261.10, 0, 2
202340.70, 0, 0
2024000, 0, 0
2025000, 0, 0

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA under power train. Newer model years have had less time to collect complaints.

What goes wrong

The same sequence shows up again and again in complaints. The tachometer starts swinging, the engine revs, and the car slows instead of speeding up. Some cars drop into one gear and stay there. Others give off a burning fluid smell. Earlier years show a different pattern: a pause when the gas pedal is pressed, then a lurch forward, and dealers often find nothing wrong.

The risk is real because failures often come at speed, in traffic. Drivers report coasting to the shoulder, stalling in intersections, and cars that would not move at all and had to be towed. One 2021 owner reports a crash after losing power at 70 mph. Other crash and injury reports involve cars that moved after being shifted into Park. No transmission fire reports appear. Replacement transmissions are often back-ordered, so cars can sit at the dealer for weeks, and some replacements fail again.

Symptoms owners report

Surging RPMs and power loss

The tachometer swings or hits redline at highway speed while the car slows or will not accelerate. Owners say this came with little or no warning and left them stuck in traffic. Several cars needed a tow.

Stuck in one gear

Some owners report the car dropping into first, second, or fifth gear and refusing to shift out, even after a restart or manual mode. One owner saw a speed sensor mismatch code afterward.

Hesitation and shudder from a stop

Common in 2018 and 2021 reports. The car pauses when the gas is pressed, then lurches or bucks forward. Some owners describe delayed engagement. Dealers often found nothing wrong, and one owner says a fuel injector swap did not fix the judder.

Fluid smell and metal shavings

Several owners smell burning fluid when the transmission fails. One 2022 owner says the dealer found metal shavings in the transmission fluid before replacing the unit.

Rolling after shifting to Park

A 2020 owner reports the car drove forward after being shifted into Park, injuring the driver. A 2018 Soul EV rolled downhill after being parked, and a 2021 rental rolled away after shifting itself into Drive.

When the problems start

Many failures come early. Owners report them between about 1,400 and 18,155 miles in 2020 cars, and at 4,300, 4,594, and 10,734 miles in 2022 cars, where one car failed twice. A 2018 car failed at 33,000 miles. A 2020 owner reports failure at 20,000 miles, and a 2021 owner lost power at 70 mph at about 96,000 miles.

Repairs and recalls

The usual fix owners report is a full replacement transmission, and some say it was refurbished. Parts are often back-ordered, with cars at the dealer for six weeks or longer. Some owners say the replacement failed again within months. Federal recall records list two recalls in this area. One covers 2018 and 2019 Soul EV parking mechanism damage, fixed with a free software update. The other covers 2023 Souls with an Idle Stop and Go oil pump controller that can overheat. Owners are told to park outside until it is repaired. Independent repair-cost data puts yearly repair cost for the model at $437.

Model yearsCampaignProblem
202323V531000Park outsideKia America, Inc. (Kia) is recalling certain 2023 Soul, Sportage, and 2023-2024 Seltos vehicles. The electronic controller for the Idle Stop & Go oil pump assembly may contain damaged electrical components that can…
2018, 201923V724000Kia America, Inc. (KIA) is recalling certain 2015-2019 Soul EV vehicles. The parking mechanism may be damaged, which can result in unintended vehicle movement when the gear shift lever is in the Park 'P' position and…

Checking a used Soul for transmission problems

  • Ask for service records showing any transmission replacement, and walk away from a car with more than one.
  • Test drive on a highway. Watch the tachometer for swinging or surging at steady speed.
  • Accelerate gently from a dead stop several times. Feel for a pause, lurch, shudder, or bucking.
  • Scan for stored codes and check the fluid for a burning smell or metal particles.
  • Check the VIN with Kia or NHTSA for open recalls, especially on 2023 cars and 2018 or 2019 Soul EVs.
  • Shift into Park on a slope and confirm the car stays put with the engine off.

For the rest of the car, use a full Kia Soul inspection checklist.

2 transmission recalls cover the Kia Soul. A VIN check shows whether the car you're looking at had its recall work done, plus accident and title history.

Look Up a VIN →

Kia Soul Transmission Problems: common questions

Which Kia Soul years have the most transmission problems?
The 2020 model year has the most owner complaints in this area by far, with 60 of 104 and the highest rate per vehicles sold. The 2018 and 2021 years follow. The 2024 and 2025 years have none, but they are too new to read much into that.
Is it safe to drive a Soul with transmission symptoms?
Treat surging RPMs or power loss as unsafe. Owners report losing power on highways and in intersections, and some had near misses or crashes. Have the car checked before driving it in traffic, and do not rely on a restart to clear it.
Does a recall cover Kia Soul transmission failure?
The recall records list two, and neither is described as a fix for sudden transmission failure. One covers Soul EV parking mechanism damage on 2018 and 2019 cars. The other covers a 2023 oil pump controller that can overheat. Check your VIN for open recalls.
How long do owners wait for a transmission repair?
Owners report replacement transmissions being back-ordered. One car waited over six weeks at the dealer, and another owner was given no estimated date for the part. Some say the replacement failed again within months.
What does a Kia Soul transmission repair cost?
The data gives no transmission repair price. Owners mostly describe a full replacement at the dealer, and the data does not show what they paid. Independent repair-cost data estimates $437 a year for the whole model, which is not a transmission figure.

Other Kia Soul problems

More on the Kia Soul

See incorrect data? Report an issue